Natural toxins in foodstuffs
To those who think "herbal" means safe, natural and nurturing,
I like to point out that deadly nightshade (belladonna), opium,
hemlock and digitalis are all herbs – but very dangerous indeed!
In fact Nature has seen fit to endow a number of plants with
the capacity to synthesize substances that are toxic to humans and
other animals. Ingesting them may produce unpleasant consequences
which are not allergic but may become confused with an allergy. As
I reported in THE FOOD ALLERGY PLAN (Unwins, London, 1985),
humans are probably able to tolerate the majority of foods only
because of the discovery of fire, which cooks away toxins
(although several plant toxins are heat-stable).
Farmers and veterinarians, who are more advanced in clinical
ecology than many doctors, have known for years that animals
become sick if they graze on certain types of plant (for example,
bulls become enraged if they eat loco weed – 'loco' being Spanish
for crazy). Many plant substances are toxic to humans in quite
small quantities, including deadly nightshade, acorns and hemlock.
Ricin, the toxic principle in caster seeds (Ricinus communis),
is one of the most poisonous substances known: a minute drop on a
needle at the tip of an umbrella was used in an infamous political
assassination on the streets of London in 1978.
The fact is that all plants, including edible ones, contain
quantities of poisons. Carrots, for example, contain a nerve
toxin: caratotoxin. And someone once pointed out that if
cabbage had to undergo the tests that drugs are now subjected to
before being pronounced fit for humans, it wouldn't pass.
Obviously, most often the amounts of poison in foods are
tolerable. Toxicity is a matter of degree.
There are a number of interesting groups of plants toxins
in our food supply. To understand them a little may help you work
out some mystifying food reactions that defy even the advice given
here in this book!
Lectins
Lectins are large protein molecules; they are toxic and also
mimic allergies. Lectins are widespread and may be up to 20 per
cent of the protein content of plants, especially of seeds and
pulses. They have the curious property of imitating
antigen-antibody reactions without actually sensitizing the immune
system.
Anti-enzymes
These interfere with body enzymes such as trypsin (a protein
digestive enzyme). In experimental animals this interference has
been shown to cause retarding of growth, abnormal hypertrophy
(enlargement) of the pancreas and, in the case of prolonged
feeding, even the formation of cancer of the pancreas. Soya-bean
protein derivatives have been shown to retain some of this effect,
leading to concern that infants fed on soya milk might suffer
growth retardation.
Goitrogens
Goitrogens are substances causing goiter or thyroid
enlargement. Soya-bean extract is in this category and goiters
have been seen in human infants fed with soya milk. Iodine appears
to counter act this effect, so infant soya milks are fortified
with iodide as a precautionary measure.
Goitrogens are a common constituent of plans belonging to the
Crucifer family (cabbage, turnip, swede, broccoli, cauliflower,
kale brussel sprout, rape and mustard seed). An epidemic goiter
seen in Tasmania is probably due to milk from cows fed on kale and
turnips.
Oestrogens
There are naturally occurring oestrogenic compounds in many
plants. These heat-stable compounds are capable of eliciting an
oestrogenic response (feminization) in experimental animals.
Recently much interest has focused on so-called "phyto-oestrogens",
some women like to use these substances in the belief that they
are somehow a natural alternative to medication for hormone
imbalances. This is partly deluded, in that pseudo-oestrogens in
plants are not the human hormone. It is possible to manufacture
natural human hormone, such as progesterone from plant sources
(such as diascorea from the wild yam) but this requires a
whole factory manufacturing process and chemical formulations: not
what I personally accept as a "natural" substances.
Moreover excess oestrogens are bad for males and equally
harmful to women already suffering from oestrogen dominance, a
condition where oestrogen is not balanced by opposing
progesterone, causing bloating, water retention and extreme mood
changes. Therefore oestrogens, naturally occurring in plants or
not, are potentially toxic.
Nerve Toxins
Also known as cholinesterase inhibitors, these affect chiefly
animals, causing paalysis and sometimes death, though humans are
occasionally afflicted. Lathyrism, a condition associated with
high intake of lathyrus bean (chickpea family), is a kind of
paralysis.
Poisons
These include prussic acid and its precursors, nicotine,
solanin, atropine and a host of others.
Antinutrients
Antinutrients are substances that interfere directly with the
absorption of vitamins, minerals and other nutrients.
Phytate occurs in several plant groups, particularly grains and
also the pulses. These are known to chelate, that is, combine with
and remove, valuable minerals such as calcium and magnesium and
trace elements such as zinc, copper and iron, which are vital for
health.
Flatulence Factors
The pulses (peas and beans) are especially noted for this
effect. The cause is low molecular weight oligosaccharides (simple
sugars), namely raffinose and stachyose. Flatulence is generally
attributed to the fact that humans do not possess the enzyme alpha
1,6-galacto-sidase necessary for breaking down these sugars.
Blowing off? see flatulence section
Psychogenics
There is growing interest in drug-like substances in plans.
Well-known are the psychedelic substances such as those in
marijuana and peyote cactus; the coca plant gives rise to cocaine
and the opium poppy is notorious for its forbidden juices. But
there have been opium-like alkalodis called exorphins, and many
other pharmacologically active substances, found in plants. These
may have beneficial effects as well as unwanted ones.
Alkaloids
These are small organic molecules, usually comprising several
carbon rings with side chains, one or more of the carbon atoms
being replaced by a nitrogen (which confers the alkalinity). About
7 to 10 per cent of all plants contain alkaloids, of which several
thousand are now known.
Famous alkaloids include nicotine, quinine, strychnine,
ergotamine and atropine. The less toxic ones, such as caffeine,
are used for pleasant social effects. The powerful ones are
hallucinogens (cannabis, LSD and mescaline).
The well-known food allergy effect of addiction, where
withdrawal from the food causes unpleasant symptoms, may be due at
least in part to the addictive properties of alkaloids present in
the food.
The action of alkaloids on the nervous system is generally to
disrupt electrochemical transmission at nerve junctions
(synapses), either preventing transmission (as in the case of the
plant poison curare) or enhancing it inappropriately (as,
for example, physostigmine). Locoism, referred to above, is of
this latter class.
Outbreaks of food poisoning due to solanine (from potatoes),
tomatine (tomatoes) and dioscorine (yams) have all been reliably
observed in either humans or domestic animals. Death due to
alkaloid overdose is fortunately uncommon in humans; in Socrates'
case (hemlock) it was deliberate murder by the state. But
subclinical alkaloid intoxication occurs all the time. The
'edible' nightshades (potatoes, tomatoes, capsicums, pepers) are
especially rich sources, but cabbage, peppercorns and many other
foodstuffs are not far behind.
Exorphins
These are morphine-like peptides derived from partially
digested grain, milk and legume proteins. Pharmacologically they
behave, when tested on isolated tissues, very much like morphine,
hence the name. It is reasonable to propose that in people whose
intestinal digestion of these foodstuffs is incomplete, exorphins
are absorbed and have the effect of a small dose of an opiate
drug-for example, patients who take wheat bran and find their
constipation gets worse. On the plus-side, the well-known effect
of pleasant somnolence after a meal is probably also due to
morphine-like activity.
Milk sickness
A disease known as milk sickness, characterized by weakness,
nausea and collapse, has occasionally reached epidemic proportions
in certain parts of the US. It probably caused the death of
Abraham Lincoln's mother. The name derives from the fact that the
disease is brought on by drinking milk from cow made ill with a
disease known as the trembles. This was eventually tracked down to
the consumption, by cattle, of a plant known as snake root (Eupatorium
rugosum), containing the chemical tremetone.
Along the same lines, lupin alkaloids have been known to be
transferred to human beings via goat's milk. Birth abnormalities
have been reported and, significantly, lupin alkaloids have the
same effect on goat offspring.
Caffeine Family (Methylxanthines)
It is commonly forgotten that caffeine and theobromine (which
occur in tea and coffee) are toxic substances. Taken in sufficient
quantities they can cause cerebral oedema (so-called 'water on the
brain), convulsions and even death, though no one has ever been
able to establish tissue damage caused by chronic ingestion at
normal levels.
Salicylates
Salicylates are aspirin-like chemicals that occur in
many fruits and vegetable. They tend to cause pharmacological
rather than allergic reactions. Adverse reactions are dose-related
and only occur in sensitive individuals who have a constitutional
predisposition.
Hypertensive Substances
These are aromatic amino compounds such as serotonin and
norepinephrine (noradrenalin), which constrict blood vessels and
thereby elevate the blood-pressure. Such substances occur in
chocolate, pineapple juice, avocado, alcohol and cheese.